Pets

Pet toys

Natural-rubber, cotton and wool pet toys without conventional plastic chewing surfaces.

A toy that goes in an animal's mouth needs scrutiny of its fill, dye, glue and attachments as well as its main material.  We favor suitable non-plastic options, while keeping size and chewing style in mind.  No toy is indestructible; supervise play and remove damaged pieces.

Filter VETTED
Sort:

KONG Extreme Natural-Rubber Ball with Hole — Medium/Large KONG Extreme Natural-Rubber Ball with Hole — Medium/Large USA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: A natural-rubber body replaces the plastic shell and fabric covering found on some fetch balls.  This black Extreme model has a central hole and a firm, bouncy feel for dogs that play hard.  Made in the USA with globally sourced materials.  Select a ball too large to swallow, supervise play and retire it if the rubber starts to split. Materials: natural-rubber compound $14.96★ 4.7 · 21,000+ ratings View on Amazon
KONG Extreme Goodie Ribbon Natural-Rubber Treat Toy — Large KONG Extreme Goodie Ribbon Natural-Rubber Treat Toy — Large USA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: Four treat pockets in a molded natural-rubber body provide a reusable feeding puzzle without a plastic shell or plush filling.  The internal ridges hold small treats in place, while the elongated shape gives dogs several places to grip.  Made in the USA with globally sourced materials.  Supervise use and discard it if pieces begin to tear away. Materials: natural-rubber compound $20.96★ 4.6 · 500+ ratings View on Amazon
KONG Puppy Binkie Natural-Rubber Toy — Small, Blue KONG Puppy Binkie Natural-Rubber Toy — Small, Blue NATURAL RUBBERUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: This soft natural-rubber toy is designed for teething puppies, with a hollow center for treats and a ring you can hold during play.  Its one-piece construction avoids fabric stuffing and a hard plastic shell.  Made in the USA.  Choose the right size, supervise chewing and replace it if damaged; KONG recommends moving on from puppy toys by nine months. Materials: natural rubber $8.96★ 4.6 · 15,000+ ratings View on Amazon
KONG Stuff-A-Ball Natural-Rubber Treat Toy — Large KONG Stuff-A-Ball Natural-Rubber Treat Toy — Large NATURAL RUBBERUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: A hollow center and deep outer grooves let you tuck treats into a natural-rubber ball instead of a rigid plastic puzzle toy.  The ridged surface gives dogs something to grip during chewing and fetch.  KONG makes it in the USA.  This Large version is sized for dogs around 30–65 lb; supervise play and discard it if it starts to break apart. Materials: natural rubber $10.96★ 4.6 · 6,000+ ratings View on Amazon
KONG Donut Natural-Rubber Chew Toy — Small/Medium KONG Donut Natural-Rubber Chew Toy — Small/Medium NATURAL RUBBERUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: This thick, textured donut gives dogs a flexible natural-rubber surface for chewing, bouncing and rolling—without a hard nylon core or plush filling.  The continuous round shape is easy to carry and chase.  Made in the USA for small-to-medium dogs.  Supervise use and remove it if damaged; dogs that quickly tear ordinary rubber need a different toy. Materials: natural rubber $9.96★ 4.5 · 96 ratings View on Amazon
KONG Ring Natural-Rubber Dog Chew Toy — Medium/Large KONG Ring Natural-Rubber Dog Chew Toy — Medium/Large USA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: This one-piece natural-rubber ring has no fabric covering, loose rope or plush stuffing.  Its rounded ridges give dogs varied surfaces to chew, with more flexibility than a hard plastic toy.  Made in the USA with globally sourced materials.  It is not indestructible or a substitute for dental care; supervise chewing and remove it when worn or damaged. Materials: natural-rubber compound $9.96★ 4.5 · 14,000+ ratings View on Amazon
KONG Extreme Tires Natural-Rubber Dog Toy — Medium/Large KONG Extreme Tires Natural-Rubber Dog Toy — Medium/Large USA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: A flexible natural-rubber tire offers an alternative to rigid plastic chews.  Its hollow inner rim can hold treats, giving dogs something to work on without a fabric cover or stuffing to pull apart.  Made in the USA with globally sourced materials.  Choose a size your dog cannot swallow, supervise play and replace the toy if damaged. Materials: natural-rubber compound $10.96★ 4.4 · 17,000+ ratings View on Amazon
KONG Natural-Rubber Ball with Cotton Rope — Small KONG Natural-Rubber Ball with Cotton Rope — Small NATURAL RUBBERCOTTONUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: A natural-rubber ball and cotton rope make this a straightforward alternative to plastic fetch toys and synthetic-fiber ropes.  The rope gives you a handle for throwing and supervised tug games.  Made in the USA.  Check the rope for fraying as well as the ball for damage, and put it away after play so your dog cannot chew off and swallow loose strands. Materials: natural rubber · cotton $11.96★ 4.1 · 2,000+ ratings View on Amazon
Auburn Leathercrafters Cotton and Leather Tug Ring Auburn Leathercrafters Cotton and Leather Tug Ring COTTONLEATHERUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: A cotton rope loop and vegetable-tanned leather ring provide two gripping surfaces without a plastic squeaker or glued assembly.  Auburn makes it in the USA from American-sourced materials and uses cotton thread for the reinforced leather sections.  The loop is useful for interactive tug, but the toy still needs supervision and replacement if the rope or leather comes apart. Materials: undyed cotton rope · vegetable-tanned leather · cotton thread $28.00 View product
Auburn Leathercrafters Flat Leather Dog Toy — Bone Auburn Leathercrafters Flat Leather Dog Toy — Bone COTTONLEATHERUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: This flat, unstuffed bone keeps the construction visible: layers of vegetable-tanned bridle leather secured with cotton stitching.  Made in the USA, it avoids the polyester stuffing and hidden plastic squeaker of many plush toys.  It is suited to supervised tossing and carrying, not being eaten; discard it when the leather or seams deteriorate. Materials: vegetable-tanned bridle leather · cotton thread $22.00 View product
Boba & Vespa Hemp and Cotton Plush Dog Bone — Medium Boba & Vespa Hemp and Cotton Plush Dog Bone — Medium ORGANIC COTTONHEMPUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: For dogs that carry and cuddle soft toys, this U.S.-made bone replaces polyester plush and stuffing with hemp canvas and organic cotton.  Cotton stitching and the absence of a squeaker keep the construction simple.  It is intended for gentle chewers, not dogs that shred their toys; spot-clean and check the seams regularly. Materials: hemp canvas · organic cotton filling · cotton thread and label $31.99 View product
Boba & Vespa Hemp and Cotton Stingray Catnip Toy Boba & Vespa Hemp and Cotton Stingray Catnip Toy ORGANIC COTTONHEMPBUCKWHEAT Why we recommend it: A hemp-canvas back and cotton-sherpa belly give cats two fabric textures to grab, with a hemp-cord tail for batting.  Inside, cotton, catnip and buckwheat hulls replace synthetic stuffing and plastic crinkle material.  Made in the USA, this is a soft play toy rather than a chew treat; check the tail and seams after play. Materials: hemp canvas and cord · organic cotton sherpa · cotton filling and thread · buckwheat hulls · organic catnip $22.99 View product
Boba & Vespa Hemp Catnip Kicker — 10 Inch Boba & Vespa Hemp Catnip Kicker — 10 Inch ORGANIC COTTONHEMPBUCKWHEAT Why we recommend it: Buckwheat hulls give this hemp kicker its rustling texture without plastic crinkle film, while cotton stuffing softens the toy and catnip encourages play.  The long shape lets a cat hold it with the front paws and kick with the back legs.  It is made in the USA and stitched with cotton thread; spot-clean rather than soaking the filling. Materials: hemp canvas · organic cotton filling and thread · buckwheat hulls · organic catnip $19.99 View product
Purrfectplay Organic Cotton Tooth Dog Toy, Small — Without Squeaker Purrfectplay Organic Cotton Tooth Dog Toy, Small — Without Squeaker ORGANIC COTTONUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: Choose the “Without Squeaker” version: both its soft fleece cover and stuffing are cotton, with no plastic squeaker hidden inside.  This small US-made toy is washable and suited to gentle, supervised play.  It is not designed for determined chewing; retire it as soon as a seam opens or filling becomes accessible. Materials: organic cotton fleece shell · organic cotton filling $10.95 View product
Purrfectplay Small Organic Cotton Mouse, No Added Catnip Purrfectplay Small Organic Cotton Mouse, No Added Catnip ORGANIC COTTONUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: Cotton fabric, cotton filling and a yarn tail give cats a small batting toy without plastic eyes or polyester stuffing.  The natural brown and green fibers need no dye, and the mouse is washable.  There is no added catnip, although the workshop handles it.  Supervise play and replace the toy if the tail or seams fray. Materials: organic cotton fabric · organic cotton batting · organic cotton yarn $8.25 View product

What we avoid

These are category-level exclusions when materials or treatments are disclosed.  Each product card explains why we recommend it and lists the disclosed materials.

BPA & BPS Phthalate plasticizers PVC Melamine