Pet toys

Pet toys in natural rubber, cotton, wool, wood, and sisal with dyes and fills identified.

Pets chew and mouth toys aggressively. Plastic toys can shed particles and leach additives that are then ingested. Natural rubber, cotton, wool, wood, and sisal with identified dyes and fills keep the mouthed materials known.

VETTED

Sort:

Ruffify Felted Wool Cat Mice, Set of 3 WOOL Why we recommend it: Soft wool felt gives these mice a yielding texture for stalking, pouncing and carrying. The three-piece set is hand washable, offering a reusable fabric toy for cats that prefer a mouse shape to a rolling ball. Materials: wool $15.99★ 4.7 · 32 ratings View on Amazon

Earthtone Solutions Felted Wool Cat Balls, 1.5 in, 6-Pack WOOL Why we recommend it: All-wool construction gives these six small balls a soft, quiet surface for batting across the floor. Hand-felted in Nepal, they offer a fiber-based play option for cats who enjoy chasing and carrying toys. Materials: wool $9.99★ 4.6 · 1,000+ ratings View on Amazon

Earthtone Solutions Wool Cat Toys, 3 Balls and 2 Mice WOOL Why we recommend it: Three wool balls and two felted mice let cats switch between rolling, chasing and carrying shapes. Handmade in Nepal, the set offers quiet fiber-based play with varied textures rather than hard rattling toys. Materials: wool $12.99★ 4.6 · 300+ ratings View on Amazon

Friendsheep Wool Pet Balls, Fairy Dust, 1.5 in, 6-Pack ORGANIC COTTONWOOL Why we recommend it: A soft felted-wool surface lets cats chase the Fairy Dust balls with less clatter than hard plastic toys. These six small balls are hand-felted in Nepal and can be spot cleaned or gently hand washed, then air dried. Materials: wool · organic cotton $14.00★ 4.6 · 400+ ratings View on Amazon

Friendsheep Wool Pet Balls, Purple Rain, 1.5 in, 6-Pack ORGANIC COTTONWOOL Why we recommend it: Densely felted wool gives the Purple Rain balls their shape all the way through, rather than a synthetic stuffing core. This six-pack is light enough for cats to bat and carry, and comes in an organic-cotton storage bag. Materials: wool · organic cotton $14.00★ 4.6 · 400+ ratings View on Amazon

KONG Classic Natural Rubber Dog Toy, Medium NATURAL RUBBERUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: Natural rubber gives the Classic its flexible chew surface and uneven bounce. The hollow center holds treats for supervised play, and the dishwasher-safe design makes food residue easier to clean out after use. Materials: natural rubber $11.96★ 4.6 · 92,000+ ratings View on Amazon

KONG Extreme Natural Rubber Dog Toy, Large NATURAL RUBBERUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: KONG’s tougher Extreme rubber is designed for dogs that work harder on their chew toys, while the treat cavity adds a food puzzle to playtime. This large, US-made version can be dishwasher cleaned; inspect it regularly for wear. Materials: natural rubber $14.96★ 4.6 · 32,000+ ratings View on Amazon

Hustle & Blush Love Ewe Wool Cat Balls, Fish & Bird, 3-Pack WOOL Why we recommend it: Wool felt and plant-based colorants give these two-inch balls a soft surface for indoor chasing and pouncing. The maker hand-felts the wool into the toys themselves, rather than wrapping a separate stuffing core. Materials: organic wool · plant-based dyes $14.69★ 4.5 · 100+ ratings View on Amazon

KONG Goodie Bone Natural Rubber Treat Toy, Medium, Red NATURAL RUBBERUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: Molded natural rubber forms both the chewable bone and the openings that grip small treats. Unlike a hollow ball, its two ends give a dog separate spots to investigate during supervised play; made in the USA. Materials: natural rubber $11.96★ 4.5 · 17,000+ ratings View on Amazon

Lucas b Natural Latex Rubber Broccoli Dog Toy, XL NATURAL LATEX Why we recommend it: A textured natural-latex body gives this broccoli toy a flexible chewing surface, with nubby bumps and a squeaker for interactive play. Lanco hand-makes and paints it in Morocco; choose it for supervised play, not destructive chewing. Materials: natural rubber · food-grade dyes $20.99★ 4.5 · 100+ ratings View on Amazon

Potaroma Wool Felt Cat Balls with Catnip, 12-Pack ORGANIC WOOL Why we recommend it: Hand-felted wool makes these 1.6-inch balls a quiet option for indoor chasing. The included catnip pouch can refresh their scent in the storage bag, so the toy’s appeal comes from its felt texture and scent rather than rattling parts. Materials: organic wool · catnip $9.48★ 4.5 · 200+ ratings View on Amazon

Earthtone Solutions Felted Wool Cat Mice, Set of 3 WOOL Why we recommend it: Hand-felted wool gives these three mice a textured surface for cats to grip and carry. The maker uses an all-wool design with quiet play in mind, making this a simple alternative to hard plastic mice. Materials: wool $13.99★ 4.4 · 400+ ratings View on Amazon

Pet Pizazz Boiled-Wool Dog Balls, Set of 3 WOOL Why we recommend it: Boiled wool gives this three-ball set a dense, soft texture for supervised fetch on floors or outdoors. The red, green and blue balls offer an all-wool play surface; put them away if your dog begins shredding the fibers. Materials: wool $14.95★ 4.3 · 500+ ratings View on Amazon

ClawClawHome Natural Rubber Dog Chew Toys, Set of 4 NATURAL RUBBER Why we recommend it: Four molded natural-rubber shapes offer different grips and textures for supervised chewing and fetch. The flexible surfaces are a rubber alternative to rigid plastic toys, with rinsable construction for routine cleanup. Materials: natural rubber $26.98★ 4.2 · 60 ratings View on Amazon

KONG Puppy Goodie Bone with Cotton Rope, XS, Pink NATURAL RUBBERCOTTONUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: Softer puppy rubber and a cotton rope offer two chewing textures in one small toy. The XS pink version is made for tiny puppies’ supervised play; retire it when the rope frays or the rubber becomes damaged. Materials: natural rubber · cotton $6.46★ 4.1 · 5,000+ ratings View on Amazon

Pet Passion Brady Organic Cotton Rope Toys, Sandy Chic, 3-Pack ORGANIC COTTON Why we recommend it: Braided organic cotton gives this three-toy set a fiber-based surface for supervised tug and fetch. The different rope shapes add variety to playtime, and the washable construction helps with cleanup between sessions. Materials: organic cotton $18.00★ 4.1 · 100+ ratings View on Amazon

Friendsheep Ocean Wool Dog Balls, Small 2 in, Set of 2 WOOL Why we recommend it: Wool all the way to the core makes these Ocean fetch balls a fiber-based alternative to synthetic-filled toys. The selected pair measures two inches each; supervise play and replace a ball if your dog starts pulling it apart. Materials: wool View product

What we avoid

These are category-level exclusions when materials or treatments are disclosed. Each product card explains why we recommend it and lists the disclosed materials.

BPA & BPS Phthalate plasticizers PVC Melamine

Pet toys

What we avoid

Related to Pet toys