Nursery

Pacifiers

Silicone and natural-rubber pacifiers without plastic shields, handles or hidden cores.

A silicone nipple alone does not make the whole pacifier free of plastic.  We examine every component and favor simple, fully specified designs.  Follow the stated age and size guidance, inspect frequently and replace damaged pacifiers.  Do not attach cords or straps during sleep.

Filter VETTED
Sort:

JollyPop Unscented Silicone Pacifiers — Newborn, 6-Pack JollyPop Unscented Silicone Pacifiers — Newborn, 6-Pack SILICONEUSA PRODUCTION Why we recommend it: JollyPop's soft silicone shield and loop handle have no hard plastic insert, making this a simple alternative to plastic-shield pacifiers.  This is the unscented newborn version for ages 0–3 months, supplied as six pacifiers.  The curved shield sits below the nose, and the one-piece design is easy to wash.  Follow the maker's inspection and cleaning instructions; JollyPop is for babies without teeth, not for chewing. Materials: medical-grade silicone $21.99★ 4.7 · 300+ ratings View on Amazon
MAM Comfort One-Piece Silicone Pacifiers — 0–3 Months MAM Comfort One-Piece Silicone Pacifiers — 0–3 Months SILICONE Why we recommend it: Unlike pacifiers with a hard plastic shield, MAM Comfort uses soft silicone for the nipple, shield and grip in one piece.  The small nipple is sized for newborns up to three months, and there are no separate pacifier parts to take apart for cleaning.  This two-pack includes a plastic carry case; use the maker's boiling method if you prefer to avoid heating that case.  Made in Europe. Materials: silicone $8.39★ 4.7 · 11,000+ ratings View on Amazon
Medela Soft Silicone Pacifiers, Pink, 6-18 Months, 2-Pack Medela Soft Silicone Pacifiers, Pink, 6-18 Months, 2-Pack SILICONE Why we recommend it: A flexible silicone shield and nipple are molded as one piece, with no hard plastic guard against your baby's mouth.  The flat, symmetrical nipple and low-cut shield keep this Swiss-made design compact.  This pink two-pack is sized for 6-18 months.  A separate plastic storage case is included; the pacifiers themselves are silicone.  Inspect before every use and replace at the first sign of damage. Materials: food-grade silicone $7.99★ 4.6 · 4,000+ ratings View on Amazon
Zoë b Organic Simply Rubber Rounded Pacifier — Small, 0–6 Months Zoë b Organic Simply Rubber Rounded Pacifier — Small, 0–6 Months NATURAL LATEX Why we recommend it: A rounded nipple and a shield with a nose cutout give this all-rubber pacifier a different fit from circular-shield designs.  The handle is rubber too, so there is no rigid plastic surround.  Made in Italy.  Expect a strong rubber scent and hand-washing care; replace every 6–8 weeks or sooner if sticky or damaged.  Contains natural-rubber latex. Materials: natural rubber latex $11.99★ 4.2 · 200+ ratings View on Amazon
Zoë b Organic Simply Rubber Symmetrical Pacifier — Small/Newborn Zoë b Organic Simply Rubber Symmetrical Pacifier — Small/Newborn NATURAL LATEX Why we recommend it: The nipple, shield and handle are made as one piece of natural rubber, with no hard-plastic core.  Its short, symmetrical nipple offers a different fit from round or angled designs.  Made in Italy.  Rubber has a noticeable scent and wears with use: replace every 6–8 weeks, or sooner if sticky or damaged.  Contains natural-rubber latex. Materials: natural rubber latex $11.99★ 4.1 · 200+ ratings View on Amazon
HEVEA Classic Orthodontic Natural Rubber Pacifiers, 3-36 Months, Two Pack HEVEA Classic Orthodontic Natural Rubber Pacifiers, 3-36 Months, Two Pack NATURAL LATEX Why we recommend it: For a baby who prefers a flattened teat, this pair offers that shape in an all-rubber pacifier rather than a rubber nipple attached to plastic.  The flexible shield and grip are molded with the teat.  Made in Malaysia.  'Orthodontic' describes the shape, not a guarantee against dental changes; avoid with latex allergy. Materials: natural rubber latex · mineral-based pigments (maker specification) $21.00 View product
HEVEA Classic Round Natural Rubber Pacifier, 3-36 Months HEVEA Classic Round Natural Rubber Pacifier, 3-36 Months NATURAL LATEX Why we recommend it: The round teat, flexible shield and grip are all natural rubber, so there is no hard plastic shield against the mouth.  Its one-piece construction avoids assembled joints, while four openings let air reach the skin around the shield.  Made in Malaysia.  Contains latex; check for tears or stickiness and follow the maker's replacement schedule. Materials: natural rubber latex · mineral-based pigments (maker specification) $13.00 View product
HEVEA Classic Symmetrical Natural Rubber Pacifiers, 3-36 Months, Two Pack HEVEA Classic Symmetrical Natural Rubber Pacifiers, 3-36 Months, Two Pack NATURAL LATEX Why we recommend it: A symmetrical teat gives another fit option without introducing a plastic shield or handle.  Both pacifiers are molded as a single piece of natural rubber, with ventilation openings and mineral-based color pigments, according to HEVEA.  Made in Malaysia.  Latex allergy rules these out; replace them when worn rather than expecting rubber to last indefinitely. Materials: natural rubber latex · mineral-based colour pigments $21.00 View product
Moyuum Macaron All-Silicone Pacifier Moyuum Macaron All-Silicone Pacifier SILICONE Why we recommend it: The nipple, shield and handle are all silicone, avoiding the hard-plastic shield found on many pacifiers.  Its open-backed shape is easy to inspect and dry after cleaning.  This South Korea-made Mango version is sized for ages 1–3 months.  The included case is polypropylene, not silicone; use it only for storage and keep it away from the baby. Materials: silicone nipple, shield and handle · polypropylene storage case $12.00 View product

What we avoid

These are category-level exclusions when materials or treatments are disclosed.  Each product card explains why we recommend it and lists the disclosed materials.

BPA & BPS Phthalate plasticizers PVC Melamine